Joel Greenblatt: The Magic of Value Investing

Joel Greenblatt is a name synonymous with value investing and 'special situations' such as spin-offs, mergers, and restructurings. His astonishing investment returns with Gotham Capital and his lucrative "Magic Formula" approach to investing have cemented his reputation in the finance world. Further contributing to his fame are his widely popular books, including 'You Can Be a Stock Market Genius' and 'The Little Book That Beats the Market.' These accomplishments have made Greenblatt one of the world's most respected and famous investors globally. In this article, we will delve deeper into his achievements and invaluable insights.

• Joel Greenblatt, co-founder of Gotham Capital, achieved extraordinary returns, with an annualized rate of about 50% from 1985 to 1994.

• Greenblatt specialized in value investing and 'special situations' like spin-offs and mergers, leveraging corporate transformations to gain market advantages.

• His "Magic Formula" strategy, detailed in 'The Little Book That Beats the Market,' focuses on investing in high-quality, undervalued companies, emphasizing long-term, disciplined investment.

• Greenblatt has written several influential finance books and teached at Columbia Business School, making complex investment strategies accessible to a wider audience.

Born on December 13, 1957, Greenblatt developed a passion for the stock market at a young age. After earning his MBA from the prestigious Wharton School of Business, he co-founded Gotham Capital in 1985, a private investment partnership that achieved astonishingly high returns.

The firm achieved an impressive annualized return of roughly 50% from 1985 to 1994 before closing to outside investors. This exemplary performance stands as one of the best in the history of funds. To put this into perspective, a $1,000 investment with Gotham Capital in 1985 would have grown to about $40,000 by 1994 before fees, assuming no withdrawals during that period. This remarkable performance is a testament to the effectiveness of Greenblatt's investment strategies and a major reason behind his stellar reputation in the investment world. This outstanding success in managing investments has been the primary contributing factor to Joel Greenblatt's net worth, which as of 2023 is estimated to be around $500 million.

Joel Greenblatt had a unique investing strategy that focused on value investing and 'special situations.' Value investing refers to the approach of buying securities that appear underpriced by some form of fundamental analysis. Special situations, on the other hand, are unusual business events that can potentially affect a company's value, such as spin-offs, mergers, and restructurings.

In essence, special situations investing involves looking for and capitalizing on opportunities that arise when a company is undergoing significant transformation. The theory is that these events can often lead to mispriced stocks, as the market is either slow to react to the changes or lacks the information or expertise to accurately assess their impact on the company's future earnings potential. Interestingly, the term 'special situations' in this context was popularized by Greenblatt himself. Here are some examples of common types of special situations:

When a parent company decides to separate a part of its operations into a new standalone entity, it's called a spin-off. In such situations, the shares of the new company are typically distributed to existing shareholders of the parent company. Spin-offs can create value because the new entity might perform better independently than as part of the parent company.

Mergers and acquisitions often create special situations as they can significantly change a company's business structure, financials, and market prospects. The stock prices of the companies involved may not immediately reflect the potential impact of the M&A transaction, creating a potential opportunity for investors.

Companies that are facing financial distress or are in the process of restructuring their debts can sometimes present attractive investment opportunities. However, these situations are high-risk and require a deep understanding of bankruptcy laws and the company's financial health.

When a company announces a share buyback or special dividend, it can impact both the company's stock price and intrinsic value. A share buyback can potentially increase a stock's value by reducing the number of outstanding shares, thereby increasing earnings per share. A special dividend, on the other hand, is often seen as a sign of a company's strong financial position, which could make the stock more attractive to investors. Thus, these announcements can create opportunities for investors.

A useful feature for tracking special situations is Keyword Alerts. Simply type any keyword, such as “spin off”, on your profile page, while searching, or directly from any transcript in the Quartr App. This feature will then notify you whenever that keyword is mentioned in company events like earnings calls, investor days, and capital market days. Plus, it offers filtering capabilities for companies you're particularly interested in.

Join 100,000+ other business enthusiasts

Sign up for Edge, our free weekly newsletter.

• Sign up

Besides investing in special situations, how exactly did Greenblatt make such strides in the finance world? A significant part of the answer lies in what we know as the "Magic Formula." Greenblatt laid out this investment strategy in his New York Times bestseller 'The Little Book That Beats the Market.' This formula, in simple terms, emphasizes investing in good companies at bargain prices. It uses two key financial metrics to rank companies and determine their attractiveness for investment: return on capital and earnings yield. This method is so-called “magic” because of its ability to systematically identify high-quality companies selling at a discount, thereby providing the investor with the potential for excellent returns.

However, like any investment strategy, it comes with its share of challenges and potential downsides. One of the biggest hurdles to achieving great returns with the Magic Formula is the requirement for patience and discipline. It's a long-term quantitative investment strategy that may not yield substantial returns in the short term. This can be challenging for investors who crave immediate results or are easily affected emotionally by market fluctuations.

Joel Greenblatt's 'The Little Book That Still Beats the Market' and 'You Can Be a Stock Market Genius' rank among the most popular books ever published in the realm of investing. In these works, Greenblatt breaks down complex financial concepts with clear, engaging, and often humorous writing, making them accessible to both seasoned investors and novices. Consequently, his books are hailed as essential reads in the field of finance and investing.

Published in 2005 and updated in 2010, "The Little Book That Beats the Market" presents the aforementioned "Magic Formula" for buying good companies at bargain prices. The book's popularity comes from its easy-to-understand approach to investing, its rejection of traditional Wall Street wisdom, and its evidence of achieving above-average returns using a simple formula. However, Greenblatt emphasizes that the Magic Formula isn't a get-rich-quick scheme; rather, it's a long-term strategy that requires patience and discipline.

In 'You Can Be a Stock Market Genius,' Greenblatt explains his special situations investment strategy in detail. The book is popular due to its reveal of often-overlooked investing tactics and accessible writing style.

In addition to his outstanding career as an investor and author, Joel Greenblatt is also a highly respected educator. He is an adjunct professor at Columbia Business School, one of the most prestigious business schools in the world, where he teaches a course on 'Value and Special Situation Investing.'

In the classroom, Greenblatt brings the same clarity and practicality that characterizes his books. He takes complex investing concepts and breaks them down into understandable, actionable insights. He doesn't merely teach theory; he shares his own real-world experiences, offering students the invaluable perspective of an experienced investor.

Greenblatt's impact as a teacher extends beyond the walls of Columbia Business School. He has also made significant efforts to educate the general public about investing, primarily through his books and public speaking engagements. His philosophy is that anyone can become a successful investor with the right tools and knowledge, a principle he has dedicated much of his life to sharing with others. In this way, he continues to have a significant impact on the world of finance and education.

From pioneering the concept of 'special situations' to creating the 'Magic Formula', Joel Greenblatt has undeniably left an indelible mark on the world of finance. His remarkable track record with Gotham Capital, insightful books, and engaging teachings offer a unique blend of theory and practice, making him a legend in the field of investing.

Ultimately, Joel Greenblatt exemplifies the power of value investing and the potential of individuals to interpret the complex world of finance. His teachings, writings, and investment strategies offer a roadmap for those aspiring to navigate the often turbulent waters of the stock market. His continued contributions to finance education underscore his dedication to the belief that sound investing principles, patience, and discipline can enable anyone to achieve financial success.